Black and White vs Color


One decision you need to make when editing is whether the image works better in color or black and white. This is mostly a personal preference and not everyone will pick the same option. In the shot above from a house boat ride near Alleppey, Kerala, India I prefer the black and white version. The trees stand out against a pale sky and draw attention to themselves. High contrast photos tend to work well as black and white. If you find that a photo has too much noise or grain in it, it might work better as black and white. I also will convert to black and white if I ended up with too many blown highlights (aka the light or white parts of the image got too bright to fix as the details are lost and you see pure white). Blown highlights don’t stand out as much in a black and white image.

So which image do you prefer above? The black and white or the color? Do you ever convert to black and white?


Minnehaha Falls in Minneapolis


Earlier in the month, I took a trip out to Minneapolis, Minnesota for a friend’s wedding. We made a long weekend of it and worked in some sightseeing. I knew Minnehaha Falls was on my list to see! It was beautiful and very popular! Finding angles to get shots without people was tricky. Another thing I knew I wanted to try was the silky water effect you so often see in water fall shots. Look at the shot above. See how the water looks smooth and continuous? Now look at the shot below–much rougher and more natural.


Smooth, silky water is very popular! So, how do you get it? You’ll need a tripod and a really slow shutter speed. If you are shooting in daylight, you’ll probably need a neutral density filter as well to drop your shutter speed down enough. The top shot I shot at ISO 100, f/22 and a speed of 1.6s.  A lower ISO number slows the shutter speed. The higher f-stop number slows the shutter speed. However, without a neutral density filter on my lens, I probably would have had a shutter speed about 1/30 given the brightness of the day. Which would not have made silk.

A neutral density filter essentially is a dark piece of glass you screw onto the end of your lens to make a bright day darker. They come in various degrees of darkness and you can buy them individually or in sets. Amazon sells a bunch of types, as does any camera store. They are handy to cut some of the brightness if shooting midday and to slow the shutter speed when you want to make water silky. They also sell graduated neutral density filters if you want only to cut the brightness on half the shot (such as the sky).

So, in sum, to make silky water:

ISO–set as low as you can (100 or 200)

F/stop–set as big a number as you can (f/22, etc)

Use a tripod–otherwise it will be blurry at such low speeds

Not a low enough speed to make it silky? –use a neutral density filter